Skip to content
JDTool
← Research

2026 Study · Illinois scorecard

In Illinois, 79 of 90 large-employer postings showed a pay range and benefits

Illinois is the fourth state with a large enough sample for its own scorecard. The protocol requires at least 30 determinate postings before a state rate is quoted, and Illinois is the fourth to reach it: 13 determinate Illinois postings from the follow-up study, plus 77 newly collected Illinois postings, for 90 in total.

79 of the 90 showed a pay range and a general description of benefits — a 87.8% pass rate (Wilson 95% confidence interval 79.4–93.0%). The Illinois grade is two-part, unlike New York's: a posting must show a pay scale AND a general description of benefits. There is no fixed-wage exception in Illinois — a single starting rate is not a pay range. A posting with a pay range but no benefits description fails, and a posting with benefits but no pay range fails.

This is a fourth scorecard, not a representative sample of Illinois postings. It describes 90 postings, nothing more. The 12 benefits-link rows in the new collection were flipped from fails to passes under an owner ruling on the statute itself, and the linked benefits page was verified live twice — see finding 3. The 4 passes graded on search-index text and the 1 partial-text pass were all confirmed live on 2026-11-15 — see findings 5 and 6.

Key findings

1. 79 of 90 Illinois postings showed a pay range and benefits

The cumulative Illinois sample is 90 determinate postings: 79 pass, 11 fail, a 87.8% pass rate (Wilson 95% confidence interval 79.4–93.0%). The interval is still wide because the sample is small — the honest reading is that Illinois postings from large employers usually show a pay range and benefits, with real uncertainty about the exact rate. This is the lowest cumulative pass rate of the state scorecards so far, and the first scorecard where the grade is two-part.

2. The new collection: 66 of 77 showed a pay range and benefits

The targeted Illinois collection added 77 determinate rows — 80 rows collected from 7 large employers on 2026-11-13, 3 of them duplicates removed by job ID — and 66 showed a pay range and benefits, a 85.7% pass rate (Wilson 95% confidence interval 76.2–91.8%). The 7 employers span healthcare, retail and grocery, food production, manufacturing, insurance, professional services and tech, and logistics. That is what the most-recent-postings design returned for these employers, but it is not a cross-section of Illinois employers or industries. The wave-only split is reported here for transparency, not as a standalone rate; the scorecard rate is the cumulative one.

3. Twelve rows rest on a benefits link — and the owner ruled the link counts

Twelve of the rows in the new collection — all from one logistics employer (I08) — show a pay range but name zero specific benefits in the posting text; the only benefits mention is the identical template line “For details on our comprehensive benefits, click here”, a hyperlink to a benefits page. Two workers graded this template differently, one fail and one indeterminate, and both flagged it for a coordinator re-grade. The coordinator had kept them as fails. The owner ruled on 2026-11-15 that the link counts, on the statute itself — 820 ILCS 112/10(b-25): “The inclusion of a hyperlink to a publicly viewable webpage that includes the pay scale and benefits satisfies the requirements for inclusion under this subsection.” The statute also provides that posting a relevant and up-to-date general benefits description in an easily accessible, central, and public location on the employer's website and referring to it in the posting satisfies the benefits requirement. The 12 rows are therefore passes, not fails.

The linked page was verified live twice, on 2026-11-14, including an independent click-through: the benefits link goes to a public 3-page 2026 benefits-statement PDF, one click, no login, no paywall. Page 1 lists medical, dental, and vision coverage, flexible spending accounts, a 401(k) with match, educational assistance up to $5,250 a year, paid vacation, sick, holiday, and bereavement leave, 2 weeks of paid parental leave, paid military leave, adoption assistance, long- and short-term disability, life and accidental death insurance, commuter benefits, and voluntary benefits; pages 2 and 3 are paid-time-off tables by job classification. The same template sits behind all 12 Illinois benefits-link rows. The Illinois flip is clean: the statute needs only a publicly viewable page showing the pay scale and benefits. (The Washington version of this flip carries extra limits, disclosed on the Washington scorecard page.) The ruled path, for the record: as collected, the cumulative was 90 determinate (67 pass, 23 fail), 74.4% (Wilson 95% confidence interval 64.6–82.3%); the ruling flipped 12 benefits-link fails to passes, giving 79 pass and 11 fail. No other grades changed.

4. One insurer's template splits cleanly: 6 fails, 4 passes

Six failures come from one large insurer (I06), and they are not borderline: each posting's full text — 417 to 750 lines fetched per page — contains no benefits description at all. The only occurrence of the word “benefits” is an equal-opportunity boilerplate sentence listing benefits among employment practices. The 4 passes from the same employer (all adjuster roles) carry a Benefits section; the 6 non-adjuster postings do not. The split is a real template difference, and it is the largest contributor to the fail count — 6 of the 11 remaining fails.

5. The pay failures are single rates, not ranges — and the search-index passes were confirmed live

Three failures from one food and consumer-goods employer (I04) are pay only: single hourly rates — $19.00, $43.69, and $38.77 — with benefits OK in each. A fourth pay failure, from a large Chicago nonprofit academic health system (I01), is a part-time Patient Care Tech posting showing “$24.26 - $24.26 (Hourly Rate)” — a single rate with min equal to max, not a range. Its benefits text is also a generic sentence only, with no specific benefits listed, unlike the bulleted Benefits list on all other rows from that employer — but the grade rests on pay, so the benefits call does not change it. A fifth pay failure, from the logistics employer (I08), is a single $22.00 rate for a part-time Handler Warehouse role in Chicago. There is no fixed-wage exception in Illinois: a single starting rate is not a pay range.

The 4 I04 passes graded on search-index text were confirmed live on 2026-11-15, with the verbatim ranges: Manufacturing Line Manager, Chicago — “The base salary range for this position is $97,300 to $133,815”; Warehousing & Logistics Supervisor, Addison — “$69,300 to $95,315”; Senior Coordinator Compliance, Security and Operations, Chicago — “$69,300 to $95,315” (the page states “This position is based in Chicago, IL”); and a second Manufacturing Line Manager, Chicago — “$109,000 to $149,875”. Benefits were confirmed on all 4. Each page briefly flashes “The Job is not available” with a spinner while its JavaScript loads, then renders fully.

6. The partial-text pass was resolved on a targeted live re-check

One professional-services row (I07, Agentic Commerce Senior Manager) returned only 76 lines of fetched text, though pay and the benefits sentence were present. The first live check found no pay or benefits on the rendered page — but it was scoped to location confirmation only and did not expand the page's lazy-loaded sections. A targeted re-check on 2026-11-15 waited for the full load and expanded all sections: pay and benefits sit inside the collapsed Qualification accordion — Illinois $122,700–$292,200, matching the search-index figure — and the benefits description is in the posting text itself (“We offer a comprehensive benefits package, including health, dental and vision coverage, 401k, paid time off, holidays and more”), plus a link to the public benefits page, which loaded with no sign-in. Chicago was confirmed again as the first location listed. The pass stands.

7. The sample is concentrated, and so are the failures

The new collection is concentrated: 7 employers, and one employer contributes 17 rows; a second employer's 10 rows are 6 pharmacist roles at distinct locations. The sample leans corporate and professional — finance, tech, healthcare management, and manufacturing management — with retail, logistics, and food-production roles as the hourly counterweight. It is not a cross-section of Illinois employers or industries. The fail count is concentrated too: the insurer contributes 6 of the 11 fails and the food and consumer-goods employer 3, so 9 of 11 fails come from two employers. A further employer in a different industry would broaden the base, and the scorecard should be read as a fourth measurement, not a state verdict.

Breakdown

SourceDeterminatePassFail
Follow-up study, Illinois13130
Targeted Illinois collection776611
Cumulative Illinois907911

Raw counts only — no rate is quoted for any employer group, because none reaches 30 determinate rows. Indeterminate rows: 6 in the follow-up study's Illinois set, 0 in the targeted collection. The as-collected alternative is disclosed in finding 3, not used.

What this adds

The follow-up study measured 12 states but quoted no state rate, because no state reached 30 determinate rows. California was the first state to clear that bar, New York the second, and Illinois is the fourth state whose sample has cleared it — Washington's sample has also cleared n ≥ 30 and its scorecard is live at 96.5% (83 of 86), so the order in which the two pages land does not change the count. This page exists to answer one question: what does the Illinois sample look like once it is large enough to quote? It does not re-argue the follow-up study's case — that is on the follow-up study's page.

Grade your postings in bulk → Check a single posting →

Methodology — summary

The sample. 90 determinate Illinois postings from large employers (1,000+ employees): 13 from the follow-up study's graded dataset and 77 from a targeted Illinois collection on 2026-11-13 (the 10 most recently posted roles per employer from their public career pages, excluding internships, contractor roles, and internal-only transfers). 80 rows were collected and 3 duplicates removed by job ID, leaving 77. Determinate means the posting text was substantial enough to grade; indeterminate and ungradable postings are excluded from the rate, not treated as passes.

The Illinois rule. Graded only against the frozen requirement dataset (DATA_VERSION 2026-10-14). Main's DATA_VERSION was bumped to 2026-11-13 by a change that added only penalty and statute metadata; the grading requirements are untouched, so grades are identical under either version. Illinois requires a pay scale AND a general description of benefits; a deadline is not required in Illinois. There is no fixed-wage exception in Illinois: a single starting rate is not a pay range. The full research protocol is on the methodology page.

The benefits-link decision. The 12 logistics-employer rows in finding 3 were first graded differently by two workers, then kept as fails by the coordinator; the owner ruled on 2026-11-15 that the hyperlink counts, on the statute itself — 820 ILCS 112/10(b-25) — and the linked benefits page was verified live twice on 2026-11-14. The ruled path is 90 determinate (67 pass, 23 fail) as collected, with 12 benefits-link fails flipped to passes, giving 79 pass and 11 fail. No other grades changed. The decision and the as-collected numbers are disclosed here rather than hidden.

Counting and de-duplication. Two workers independently picked the same logistics employer. Their sets overlapped on 3 postings, confirmed identical by job ID; one worker's copies were dropped and the other's kept. The employer's rows were merged under the single code I08 (17 rows: 10 from one worker plus 7 unique rows from the other), and the I02 code was retired. The merged dataset therefore has 7 distinct employers, not 8, and 77 rows, not 80. No row in the new collection matches any follow-up Illinois row. Two Manufacturing Line Manager rows for Chicago from the same employer are distinct requisitions with different salary bands and published dates and were counted separately, following the follow-up study's precedent. Same-title repeats at different locations are distinct requisitions and were counted separately.

Evidence tiers and the live re-checks. 72 rows were graded on full posting text, 4 on search-index text (all from the food and consumer-goods employer, whose detail pages return a JavaScript shell on direct open), and 1 on partial text plus search-index (a professional-services role whose fetch returned only 76 lines, though pay and the benefits sentence are present). Under the fetch-miss rule, a full-text fail requires substantial posting text retrieved with the required element absent; thin, empty, or incomplete fetched text is indeterminate, never a fail. All five non-full-text passes were confirmed live on 2026-11-15: the 4 search-index passes with their verbatim salary ranges (finding 5) and the partial-text pass inside its collapsed accordion (finding 6). The linked benefits page behind the 12 benefits-link rows was verified live twice on 2026-11-14.

Baseline check (no discrepancy). Unlike California, the follow-up study's Illinois baseline reconciles: the graded dataset shows 13 determinate (13 pass, 0 fail), 100.0% (Wilson 95% confidence interval 77.2–100.0%), with 6 indeterminate, matching the published table exactly. No baseline correction was needed, and this scorecard uses the auditable 13.

Anonymization. Employers are not named. Collection employers are referred to only by sector and location, and by codes I01–I08. Anonymized datasets are available on request from the press contact.

Honest limits

This restraint is deliberate. A study that overclaims gets one news cycle and zero repeat citations; a study that's honest about its limits gets cited every year.

Press

For questions about the data or the method, contact jobdescriptiontool@gmail.com.

jobdescriptiontool.com is a free tool for writing job descriptions and checking them against state pay-transparency requirements, with a pay-transparency checker covering 15 U.S. jurisdictions.