Skip to content
JDTool
← Research

2026 Study · New York scorecard

In New York, 83 of 89 large-employer postings showed a pay range

New York is the second state with a large enough sample for its own scorecard. The protocol requires at least 30 determinate postings before a state rate is quoted, and New York is the second to reach it: 13 determinate New York postings from the follow-up study, plus 76 newly collected New York postings, for 89 in total.

83 of the 89 showed a pay range — a 93.3% pass rate (Wilson 95% confidence interval 86.1–96.9%). The 3 failures in the new collection are a blank salary-range field on a hospital attending posting in Albany and a single $17.00 rate, not a range, on two lot associate postings in Rochester and Buffalo. New York requires a pay range only, so the grade is binary on pay: a full-text posting with a pay range passes, a full-text posting without one fails.

This is a second scorecard, not a representative sample of New York postings. It describes 89 postings, nothing more. The three failures in the new collection were confirmed by a live-browser re-check on 2026-11-13 — see finding 4.

Key findings

1. 83 of 89 New York postings showed a pay range

The cumulative New York sample is 89 determinate postings: 83 pass, 6 fail, a 93.3% pass rate (Wilson 95% confidence interval 86.1–96.9%). The interval is narrower than the California scorecard's because the sample is larger, but it is still wide — the honest reading is that New York postings from large employers usually show a pay range, with real uncertainty about the exact rate.

2. The new collection: 73 of 76 showed a pay range

The targeted New York collection added 76 determinate rows — 77 rows collected from 8 large employers on 2026-11-13, 1 of them indeterminate — and 73 showed a pay range, a 96.1% pass rate (Wilson 95% confidence interval 89.0–98.6%). The 8 employers span healthcare, retail, banking, tech, and media. That is what the most-recent-postings design returned for these employers, but it is not a cross-section of New York employers or industries. The wave-only split is reported here for transparency, not as a standalone rate; the scorecard rate is the cumulative one.

3. Nine rows were re-graded, then confirmed as passes by a live re-check

A large New York City bank's 10 collected rows were first graded as 9 fails and 1 indeterminate, after each official career page was fetched twice and showed no pay range. The fetches themselves looked systematically broken, and an independent re-fetch of 2 of the 9 detail pages confirmed it: both end mid-word — “build a caree” — at the same point, with no pay section, benefits section, or closing content rendered at all. The pay section this employer publishes sits past the truncation point. Under the fetch-miss rule, incomplete text is indeterminate, never a fail — so all 9 rows were re-graded to indeterminate. A live-browser re-check of all 10 rows on 2026-11-13 then resolved the question on rendered-page evidence: 9 showed an explicit New York pay range on the fully rendered page and are now passes, and the 10th — a Relationship Banker posting for the Manhattan East area — is still indeterminate because its live page 404s. It is not a fail: the page is unavailable, not a rendered page with no pay range. The as-collected alternative — 89 determinate (74 pass, 15 fail), 83.1% (Wilson 95% confidence interval 74.0–89.5%), counting the 9 rows as fails as first graded — is now superseded by the live check and is stated here for the record, not as a live alternative. The scorecard uses the live-verified 89 determinate (83 pass, 6 fail), 93.3%.

4. The 3 failures in the new collection were confirmed live

The 3 failures are an OBGYN Generalist Attending posting in Albany, whose “Salary Range:” field is blank, and two Lot Associate postings — one in Rochester, one in Buffalo — each showing a single $17.00 rate, not a range. All three were confirmed by a live-browser re-check on 2026-11-13: the OBGYN page shows a blank Salary Range field and no dollar amount anywhere, and both Lot Associate pages show only the single $17.00 rate with no upper bound. They stand as fails, and the fail count stands at 6.

5. The sample is pass-heavy and concentrated

The new collection is pass-heavy (73 of 76) and concentrated: 8 employers, and the sample leans corporate and professional — finance, tech, media, and healthcare management — with retail store roles as the hourly counterweight. It is not a cross-section of New York employers or industries. A further employer in a different industry would broaden the base, and the scorecard should be read as a second measurement, not a state verdict.

Breakdown

SourceDeterminatePassFail
Follow-up study, New York13103
Targeted New York collection76733
Cumulative New York89836

Raw counts only — no rate is quoted for any employer group, because none reaches 30 determinate rows. Indeterminate rows: 1 in the follow-up study's New York set, 1 in the targeted collection (a Relationship Banker posting whose live page 404s). The as-collected alternative — 89 determinate (74 pass, 15 fail), 83.1% (Wilson 95% confidence interval 74.0–89.5%), counting 9 bank rows as fails as first graded — is superseded by the live re-check, which showed a New York pay range on all 9 rendered pages; it is stated here for the record.

What this adds

The follow-up study measured 12 states but quoted no state rate, because no state reached 30 determinate rows. The California scorecard was the first state to clear that bar; this page is the second, and it exists to answer one question: what does the New York sample look like once it is large enough to quote? It does not re-argue the follow-up study's case — that is on the follow-up study's page.

Grade your postings in bulk → Check a single posting →

Methodology — summary

The sample. 89 determinate New York postings from large employers (1,000+ employees): 13 from the follow-up study's graded dataset and 76 from a targeted New York collection on 2026-11-13 (the 10 most recently posted roles per employer from their public career pages, excluding internships, contractor roles, and internal-only transfers). Determinate means the posting text was substantial enough to grade; indeterminate and ungradable postings are excluded from the rate, not treated as passes.

The New York rule. Graded only against the frozen requirement dataset (DATA_VERSION 2026-10-14). Main's DATA_VERSION was bumped to 2026-11-13 by a change that added only penalty and statute metadata; the grading requirements are untouched, so grades are identical under either version. New York requires a pay range only; benefits and deadline are not required in New York. A single starting rate is not a pay range, and “Base Pay + Bonus” with no figures is not a range. The full research protocol is on the methodology page.

The re-grade. The 9 rows re-graded from fail to indeterminate (finding 3) were re-graded under the fetch-miss rule: a full-text fail requires substantial posting text retrieved with no pay anywhere, and thin, empty, or incomplete fetched text is indeterminate, never a fail. A live-browser re-check then converted all 9 to passes on rendered-page evidence. The re-grade is disclosed here rather than hidden, and the superseded as-collected alternative is stated alongside it for the record.

The live re-checks. The 3 failures in the new collection were confirmed by a live-browser re-check on 2026-11-13 and stand as fails. The 4 passing rows graded on search-index text rather than completed detail fetches (three auto-service roles and one store-coach role, where detail fetches hit rate limits or truncated) were also re-checked live: three confirmed, and the fourth — an auto-service team-leader role — no longer loads (its live page 404s), so that row stays a pass on the captured text, with search-index evidence only. The 9 re-graded bank rows were converted to passes by the same live re-check; one bank row is still indeterminate because its live page 404s.

Baseline check (no discrepancy). Unlike California, the follow-up study's New York baseline reconciles: the graded dataset shows 13 determinate (10 pass, 3 fail), 76.9% (Wilson 95% confidence interval 49.7–91.8%), with 1 indeterminate, matching the published table exactly. No baseline correction was needed, and this scorecard uses the auditable 13.

Counting and de-duplication. No row in the new collection matches any follow-up New York row, and no title-and-location duplicates exist within the new collection. Same-title repeats at different locations are distinct requisitions at distinct sites and were counted separately, following the follow-up study's precedent of counting repeated identical-title postings as separate rows.

Anonymization. Employers are not named. Collection employers are referred to only by sector and location. Anonymized datasets are available on request from the press contact.

Honest limits

This restraint is deliberate. A study that overclaims gets one news cycle and zero repeat citations; a study that's honest about its limits gets cited every year.

Press

For questions about the data or the method, contact jobdescriptiontool@gmail.com.

jobdescriptiontool.com is a free tool for writing job descriptions and checking them against state pay-transparency requirements, with a pay-transparency checker covering 15 U.S. jurisdictions.